FHA vs Conventional vs VA in Louisville: 2026 Payment Math

by Tamara West

Buyer Strategy · Louisville KY & Southern Indiana

FHA vs. Conventional vs. VA: Same Louisville House, Three Monthly Payments (2026)

A plain-English walk-through of the three most common home loans, with real numbers on a typical Louisville home.

Quick Answer

We priced the same $290,000 Louisville home three ways at mid-November 2026 rates. A VA loan costs about $2,485 a month and needs no down payment. An FHA loan costs about $2,518 a month with 3.5% down. A conventional loan costs about $2,572 a month with 5% down. If you can get a VA loan, it is usually the cheapest. If you cannot, FHA usually has the lower monthly payment for buyers with average credit. Buyers with strong credit who plan to stay put for years often do better with conventional, because its extra insurance charge eventually goes away and FHA's usually does not.

About $2,485VA: $0 down About $2,518FHA: 3.5% down About $2,572Conventional: 5% down
$290,000Typical Louisville home price, Oct 2026 $541,287Most you can borrow with FHA in Kentucky (2026) About $87Monthly gap between highest and lowest

Rates are Mortgage Research Center averages reported by Fortune on November 12, 2026: VA 6.598%, FHA 6.486%, conventional 7.107%. Every payment includes about $302 a month for property tax and $291 for homeowners insurance. These are estimates to help you compare, not a loan offer.

Most buyers pick a loan the way they pick a checkout line: whichever one the lender points to first. But when rates are near 7%, the type of loan can change your payment, the cash you need, and how fast you build wealth in the home.

I worked in mortgage lending for years before I became a broker. This is the same walk-through I give buyers at my kitchen table, in plain English, with one house and three loans.

The house has one price. The loan decides what that price costs you every month.

Want me to run these numbers on your budget? No pressure, just clarity.

Talk With Tamara

First, the words you will hear

Lenders use a lot of shorthand. Here is what it means in everyday words.

Term What it means Example
Down payment The cash you put toward the price on day one. The rest is borrowed. 5% of $290,000 is $14,500.
Interest rate What the lender charges you to borrow, as a yearly percentage. 7% means about $7 a year for every $100 you owe.
Mortgage insurance A monthly charge that protects the lender (not you) if a buyer with a small down payment stops paying. About $126 a month in this example.
PMI The name for mortgage insurance on a conventional loan. It can be removed later. Goes away once you owe 78% of the home's original value.
MIP The name for mortgage insurance on an FHA loan. Includes a one-time fee plus a monthly charge. With under 10% down, it stays for the life of the loan.
VA funding fee A one-time fee on VA loans, usually added to the loan instead of paid in cash. 2.15% for most first-time VA buyers. $0 if you receive VA disability pay.
Equity The part of the home you actually own: its value minus what you still owe. A $290,000 home with $260,000 owed = $30,000 of equity.

Which loan has the lowest monthly payment in Louisville right now?

VA is lowest, then FHA, then conventional. The difference between the highest and lowest payment is about $87 a month, or about $1,000 a year.

  Conventional FHA VA
Cash down on day one $14,500 (5%) $10,150 (3.5%) $0
Interest rate (Nov 12, 2026 average) 7.107% 6.486% 6.598%
One-time fee added to the loan None $4,897 $6,235
Total amount borrowed $275,500 $284,747 $296,235
Monthly loan payment (principal + interest) $1,853 $1,797 $1,892
Monthly mortgage insurance About $126 About $128 None
Property tax + homeowners insurance $593 $593 $593
What you pay each month About $2,572 About $2,518 About $2,485
What this means for youThe VA loan borrows the most money but still has the lowest payment, because it has no monthly mortgage insurance. The FHA loan has the lowest interest rate, which is why it beats conventional each month even though both charge insurance.

How we built the FHA number, step by step

FHA is the trickiest to follow, so here is every step.

Step What happens Result
1. Start with the price The home costs $290,000. $290,000
2. Subtract your down payment 3.5% of $290,000 is $10,150. You borrow $279,850
3. Add FHA's one-time fee 1.75% of $279,850 is $4,897. It is added to the loan, not paid in cash. Loan becomes $284,747
4. Figure the loan payment $284,747 over 30 years at 6.486%. $1,797 a month
5. Add FHA's monthly insurance 0.55% of $279,850 a year, split into 12 months. $128 a month
6. Add tax and homeowners insurance Same for every loan on this house. $593 a month
7. Total $1,797 + $128 + $593 About $2,518 a month

How does each loan work?

Conventional: the "good credit" loan

Who it is built for: buyers with solid credit and at least 3% to 5% saved.

What you pay: if you put down less than 20%, you pay PMI each month. The better your credit, the cheaper it is. A common rule of thumb is $30 to $70 a month for every $100,000 you borrow, so about $83 to $193 a month on this home.

The good news: PMI does not last forever. By law, you can ask your lender to remove it once you owe 80% of what the home was worth when you bought it, and it must come off on its own at 78%. On this loan that takes about 11 to 12 years. Extra payments get you there faster, and some lenders will remove it early after a new appraisal if your home has gone up in value.

What this means for youIf your credit is strong, conventional often costs about the same as FHA today and gets cheaper later when PMI comes off.

FHA: the "easier to qualify" loan

Who it is built for: buyers with less saved or credit that is still being built. You can qualify with 3.5% down and a credit score as low as 580.

What you pay: FHA charges insurance two ways. First, a one-time fee of 1.75% that is usually added to your loan. Second, a monthly charge of 0.55% of the loan per year for most buyers.

The catch: if you put down less than 10%, that monthly insurance stays for as long as you have the loan. The usual way to drop it is to refinance into a conventional loan later, which depends on future rates and your credit at that time.

A helpful limit: FHA lets you borrow up to $541,287 for a single-family home in every Kentucky county in 2026, which covers most Louisville homes.

What this means for youFHA's lower rate makes it cheaper each month right now for many buyers. Just know the insurance is likely permanent unless you refinance.

VA: the "earned benefit" loan

Who it is built for: eligible veterans, active-duty service members, and some surviving spouses.

What you pay: usually no down payment and no monthly mortgage insurance. Most first-time VA buyers pay a one-time funding fee of 2.15%, usually added to the loan. If you receive VA disability compensation, that fee is $0.

The catch: because you borrow the full price plus the fee, you start with very little equity. That matters most if you might sell within a few years.

More detail is in our VA loan guide for Fort Knox, Elizabethtown and Radcliff.

What this means for youIf you qualify for VA, it is usually the lowest payment and the least cash out of pocket.

What does each loan cost over five years?

VA leaves the most cash in your pocket. Conventional builds the most equity. Here is the same home after five years, assuming its value does not change.

After 5 years Conventional FHA VA
Cash you put down $14,500 $10,150 $0
Total of 60 monthly payments (loan + mortgage insurance) About $118,741 About $115,526 About $113,492
What you still owe About $259,627 About $266,512 About $277,619
Equity (the part you own) About $30,373 About $23,488 About $12,381

Tax and homeowners insurance are the same for all three, so they are left out here. If home values rise, all three gain equity equally on top of these numbers.

What this means for youFHA saves you about $4,350 at closing and about $54 a month now. Conventional gives you about $6,900 more equity after five years. VA costs the least out of pocket but builds equity slowest at first. Which matters more depends on whether cash today or equity later is more important to you.

Want to see homes that fit the payment you are comfortable with?

Start Your Home Search

Which loan is best for me?

Start with your eligibility, then your credit, then how long you plan to stay.

If this sounds like you... Usually start with... Why
You served, or are serving, and are VA-eligible VA No down payment and no monthly insurance
Your credit score is under about 680 FHA Lower rate and easier approval; PMI on conventional gets pricey
Your credit is 740 or higher and you have 5% or more Conventional PMI is cheap and comes off later
You have less than 5% saved FHA, or a 3% down conventional loan if you qualify Less cash needed up front
You may sell within about 5 years Compare both carefully Up-front savings matter more when you stay a short time
You plan to stay 10 years or more Conventional, or FHA with a plan to refinance FHA's permanent insurance adds up over time

Does the answer change in Southern Indiana, Shepherdsville or Elizabethtown?

The math works the same everywhere. Only the price and tax numbers change.

  • Elizabethtown and Hardin County: many buyers near Fort Knox are VA-eligible, so VA is often the place to start. See Elizabethtown closing costs, including a VA column.
  • Shepherdsville: the typical price was $321,500 in October 2026, so each payment above runs about $200 a month higher.
  • Southern Indiana: Indiana caps property tax on your home at 1% of its assessed value, which can lower the tax line and narrow the gap between loans a little. Ask your lender to confirm loan limits for Clark and Floyd counties.
  • Help with cash to close: Kentucky Housing Corporation offers first-time buyer loans and down payment assistance that pair with most of its loan programs.

Putting it together: three example buyers

Simplified examples to show how the numbers work, not recommendations.

1 Buyer A: a veteran moving for a job near Fort KnoxUses VA with $0 down. Pays about $2,485 a month on a $290,000 home, with no mortgage insurance, and keeps savings for moving and furniture.
2 Buyer B: a first-time buyer with a 650 credit score and $14,000 savedUses FHA with 3.5% down. Pays about $2,518 a month and keeps about $4,350 more in savings than a 5% conventional loan would allow. Plans to refinance later once credit and equity improve.
3 Buyer C: 760 credit score, 5% down, staying 10 yearsGets a PMI quote around $69 a month, so the conventional payment is about $2,515, the same as FHA. Because PMI comes off later, conventional wins over time.

Common mistakes when choosing a loan

1 Comparing interest rates instead of full paymentsFHA's lower rate comes with insurance. Always compare the total monthly payment.
2 Not asking how long mortgage insurance lastsConventional PMI ends; FHA's usually does not with less than 10% down.
3 Assuming VA is only for retireesActive-duty service members and many veterans qualify. It is worth checking.
4 Getting only one quoteRates and PMI prices differ by lender. Compare two or three on the same day.
5 Forgetting about closing costsThe down payment is not the only cash you need. See Louisville buyer closing costs.

Your next steps

1 Check your credit scoreIt decides your PMI price and which loan makes sense.
2 Ask a lender for FHA and conventional quotes on the same dayCompare the full monthly payment for the same price.
3 If you have served, request your VA Certificate of EligibilityYour lender can usually pull it for you.
4 See whether KHC assistance fitsIt can lower the cash you need at closing.
5 Set your budget by monthly payment, not priceThen shop homes that fit. See the Louisville home buying process.

Frequently asked questions

Is FHA or conventional better in Louisville right now?

For buyers with average credit, FHA usually has the lower monthly payment because its rate is lower: about $2,518 versus $2,572 on a $290,000 home in November 2026. For buyers with strong credit who plan to stay many years, conventional often wins because its PMI can be removed and FHA's insurance usually cannot.

What is the FHA loan limit in Kentucky for 2026?

The 2026 FHA loan limit for a one-unit home is $541,287 in every Kentucky county, including Jefferson, Bullitt and Hardin.

How much is FHA mortgage insurance?

Most FHA buyers pay a one-time 1.75% fee, usually added to the loan, plus 0.55% of the loan per year, paid monthly. With less than 10% down, it lasts for the life of the loan.

Is a VA loan always the best choice if I qualify?

Usually, because it needs no down payment and has no monthly mortgage insurance. The trade-offs are the funding fee, unless you are exempt, and slower early equity. If you have a large down payment and strong credit, compare a conventional quote too.

How long does PMI last on a conventional loan?

You can ask to remove it once you owe 80% of the home's original value, and it ends automatically at 78%. On a 5% down loan at about 7.1%, that takes roughly 11 to 12 years. Extra payments shorten it, and some lenders allow early removal with a new appraisal if your home's value has risen.

The bottom line

On a typical $290,000 Louisville home, the three loans land within about $90 a month of each other. The bigger differences are how much cash you need, whether the insurance ever goes away, and how fast you build equity. If you qualify for VA, start there. If not, your credit score and how long you plan to stay will point you to FHA or conventional. Get both quotes on the same day and compare the full payment.

Related Reading

VA Loans Near Fort Knox, Elizabethtown and Radcliff
Eligibility, the funding fee and local tips.
KHC Down Payment Assistance
Help with cash to close for eligible buyers.
Louisville Mortgage Rates: Ways to Lower Your Payment
Rate options beyond loan type.
Mortgage Rate Buydowns in Louisville
When paying points or a seller buydown makes sense.
Louisville Buyer Closing Costs (2026)
The cash you need beyond the down payment.
Elizabethtown Closing Costs: About $12,100 on a $320K Home
Conventional vs. VA cash to close.
The Louisville Home Buying Process, Step by Step
Where the loan fits in the full timeline.
Moving to Louisville KY: 2026 Relocation Guide
Monthly costs by area for relocating buyers.

Ready to compare loans on a real Louisville or Southern Indiana home? Let's run your numbers together.

Explore Greater Louisville Real Estate

Tamara West

KY & IN Realtor, Epique – KY Area Leader

502-819-2211  |  tamara@tamarawestrealtor.com  |  GreaterLouisvilleLiving.com

Your Realtor for Life.

Sources

Home price: Flexmls Louisville single-family median, October 2026. Freddie Mac's weekly 30-year average was 7.11% on November 12, close to the conventional rate used here. All payments are illustrative estimates; your rate and mortgage insurance depend on your credit and lender.

GET MORE INFORMATION

Tamara West

Tamara West

Broker Associate License ID: 247867

+1(502) 819-2211

Name
Phone*
Message